Back-to-back rollovers and Part IVA – Commissioner’s guidance released

The long-awaited PCG 2026/D5 Back-to-back CGT rollovers and Part IVA of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (PCG 2026/D5)[1] has been released and, for clients contemplating commercially driven multi-step restructures, it takes a more restrictive approach than many expected.

There is a tension at the heart of the draft Guideline.

The Australian Taxation Office (ATO) accepts that there is nothing in the tax law that prevents successive CGT rollovers from applying where the requirements of each rollover are satisfied. However, it then takes a broad approach to when the combination of those rollovers may attract Part IVA (the general anti-avoidance regime) scrutiny. PCG 2026/D5 says that the absence of an express prohibition on back-to-back rollovers does not prevent Part IVA applying and identifies certain “interdependent” rollovers as higher risk.

In other words: getting the technical rollover analysis right may only be the beginning of the analysis.

For taxpayers undertaking planned restructures, that matters. If the first rollover was undertaken as part of an overarching plan that contemplated the second, the ATO may regard the steps as interdependent. If the intermediate step has little commercial or practical utility beyond facilitating the next rollover, the arrangement may move into the higher-risk category.

The result is that the draft Guideline’s lower-risk zone appears to provide relatively limited comfort for planned multi-step restructures.

Need to know:

  • Technical availability provides limited comfort – The ATO expressly acknowledges that there is no rule requiring a gain disregarded under one CGT rollover to be brought to account before another rollover can apply. However, the Commissioner treats their planned combination as a potential anti-avoidance concern (in effect, Part IVA only comes into play once the requirements of each rollover are satisfied).
  • “Interdependence” captures ordinary transaction planning – The broad focus on a common plan, overarching arrangement or conditional steps potentially captures most deliberately sequenced restructures.
  • An overall commercial purpose may not be enough – A genuine commercial rationale for the transaction as a whole does not necessarily put the arrangement into the lower-risk category. The ATO focuses on each step and so if the first step principally enables the second rollover and lacks independent commercial utility Part IVA can apply.
  • Three tax outcomes drive the concern – (a) Deferral or elimination of gains, (b) Cost base or consolidation tax cost uplifts and (c) Increased depreciation or capital allowance deductions.
  • Consolidation step-ups are squarely in focus – Sequences producing ACA uplifts or increased asset tax costs appear particularly exposed, even where the broader transaction has a genuine commercial objective.
  • The lower-risk examples offer a narrow pathway – The examples appear to reserve meaningful comfort for a later transaction arising independently, rather than one contemplated when the first rollover was undertaken. In practical terms, the distinction looks closer to “unrelated subsequent event”.
  • Daylight does not cleanse the transaction – A substantial interval between rollovers will not assist if both were contemplated as part of the original plan.

If the Commissioner’s approach in PCG 2026/D5 is adopted, the practical availability of back-to-back CGT rollovers may be significantly curtailed.

Many commercial restructures and succession transactions require a series of rollover steps to achieve an intended ownership outcome.

The draft PCG suggests that where an intermediate entity or transaction step is undertaken principally to access a subsequent rollover, the Commissioner may regard the arrangement as presenting a heightened Part IVA risk. As a result, taxpayers may be reluctant to rely on back-to-back rollover relief even where there is no substantive change in underlying economic ownership and the transaction is otherwise consistent with the policy rationale underpinning the rollover provisions.

However, this article questions the Commissioner’s approach, which in our view reads more like a taxpayer alert than practical guidance.

Why do we have rollovers at all?

The basic policy underlying virtually every CGT rollover is that a taxpayer should not be forced to realise a tax liability merely because legal ownership arrangements change where there has not yet been a substantive economic realisation of value.

Relevantly, the CGT provisions contain multiple examples in which Parliament expressly contemplated and provided rules for assets moving through successive rollover transactions. Section 115-30 (which contains special rules about time of acquisition for CGT purposes) repeatedly refers to an “unbroken series of roll-overs” and traces acquisition history back to the first rollover in the chain. Section 328-475 likewise preserves the consequences of a prior Subdivision 152-E rollover following a subsequent Subdivision 328-G restructuring rollover.

These provisions demonstrate that the existence of back-to-back or sequential rollovers is not anomalous within the legislative scheme; rather, it is an outcome for which the legislation expressly caters.

The problems with PCG 2026/D5

The main problems with PCG 2026/D5 are the lack of real-world examples and the absence of any distinction drawn between:

  • internal restructures with no real change in economic ownership (which all of the ATO’s higher-risk examples involve), and
  • genuine M&A transactions involving third parties and substantive economic change, where there is no economic realisation of value.

No Part IVA analysis

Notably, for guidance on Part IVA, there is no discussion of the factors relevant to a Part IVA determination.

The law requires that the Commissioner weighs eight statutory factors to determine the objective dominant purpose of the scheme:

  • the manner in which the arrangement was entered into or carried out
  • the form and substance of the arrangement
  • the timing of the arrangement (e.g. proximity to a third-party sale)
  • the result achieved under the tax law
  • any change in the financial position of the taxpayer
  • any change in the financial position of any connected or related person
  • any other consequences for the taxpayer or related parties
  • the nature of any connection between the taxpayer and related parties

The above detailed considerations are absent in the PCG and the analysis in the high risk examples are reduced to assertions of artificiality.

Also, there is no mention of section 177C(2) which provides that where a taxpayer merely exercises a statutory choice in circumstances that arise naturally, the resulting tax outcome is generally not treated as a Part IVA tax benefit. Where the scheme is undertaken to create the necessary conditions for the choice or election to be available, the protection in s 177C(2)(a) may be lost.

Doing what the PCG does not

As a thought experiment,  lets carefully evaluate the prescribed factors in section 177D(2) as they might be applied to Example 2.

Any Part IVA analysis is dependent on the facts. That said, the examples in PCG 2026/D5 do not provide enough detail to offer meaningful guidance on the Commissioner’s position.

Example 2 key facts (condensed)

  • Mary operates a business as a sole trader and wishes to merge it with a business already operated by her and her three sisters through Sisters Co.
  • A direct transfer of Mary’s business assets to Sisters Co would trigger a capital gain for Mary, with no CGT rollover available.
  • Mary incorporates New Co, wholly owned by her, and transfers her business assets to New Co, claiming Subdivision 122-A rollover relief.
  • The transfer to New Co is intended only as an intermediate step and New Co has no separate commercial or operational role in the business.
  • Sisters Co then acquires the shares in New Co, with Mary receiving shares in Sisters Co and claiming Subdivision 124-M scrip-for-scrip rollover relief.
  • As a result, the capital gain that would otherwise have arisen on a direct transfer of the business assets to Sisters Co is deferred.
  • The arrangement involves back-to-back CGT rollovers, with New Co used solely as an interposed entity between Mary and Sisters Co.
  • The Commissioner’s key assertion is that in these circumstances, the transfer of assets to New Co served no commercial or practical function but to act as an intermediate step to put Mary into a position to choose the Subdivision 124-M CGT rollover and thereby defer the capital gain she would have otherwise realised on transferring her business asset directly to Sisters Co.

The statement that New Co has “no commercial or practical function” is a characterisation that requires examination; it is not a substitute for that examination. As discussed below, placing assets in a corporate vehicle and then having Sisters Co acquire that vehicle rather than directly acquiring assets may have a significant commercial rationale.

More importantly, a conclusion like this does not of itself determine whether Part IVA applies.

What the law requires is a careful evaluation of the eight matters prescribed by s 177D(2) to ultimately form a conclusion as to whether or not the dominant purpose of the relevant parties was to obtain a tax benefit.

The inquiry is objective and the conclusion about dominant purpose is drawn from the eight statutory matters, not from the participants’ subjective motives (what Mary wants or wishes is irrelevant). The question is whether obtaining the tax benefit was the “most influential and prevailing or ruling purpose” of entering into or carrying out the particular scheme.

The factors are not eight separate conditions that must each be satisfied, nor is the result determined by counting how many favour a tax-purpose conclusion. Their significance depends on the evidence and their relative probative weight – hence the importance of the facts.

Evaluating example 2

Factor in s 177D(2) High Court’s reasoning Application to Example 2, including criticism of the Commissioner’s analysis and potential weight
(a) The manner in which the scheme was entered into or carried out. Examine the actual implementation and its context. Identify what explains the particular course adopted.
Application:

Incorporating a sole trader business and then bringing that company under an existing corporate group is capable of being an intelligible commercial sequence.

It creates a corporate vehicle holding Mary’s business, followed by an acquisition of that vehicle through a share exchange.

Criticism:

The Commissioner labels the incorporation as an intermediate step without explaining why that sequence lacks commercial significance. Being an intermediate step does not itself make a step commercially unnecessary.

Potential weight:

Not necessarily adverse. Possibly favourable for the taxpayer.

It could support a commercial restructuring explanation if New Co is intended to hold or operate the business as a subsidiary. It would point more strongly towards tax purpose if the evidence showed the additional company was unnecessary to the intended structure and existed only to secure the rollover outcome.

A holding company/subsidiary structure has a real, legal and commercial benefits in terms of ring fencing of risk and structuring financing irrespective of the tax consequences.

(b) The form and substance of the scheme. Identify the legal changes and evaluate their substantive significance.

 

 

Application:

The arrangement makes two substantive changes:

  • Mary’s business becomes corporately held, and
  • ownership of that corporate vehicle moves into Sisters Co. The proposed endpoint includes shared ownership and control, rather than Mary simply retaining her former position while crystallising a tax advantage.

Direct transfer would place the assets in Sisters Co. The implemented arrangement places them in a subsidiary. That distinction could be central to the commercial design.

Criticism:

The Commissioner effectively treats those endpoints as equivalent without examining the function of separate corporate ownership.

Potential weight:

Potentially significant support for commercial purpose.

The strength depends on whether the subsidiary structure has a substantive operating, risk-management, governance or strategic role. Corporate form alone is not enough, but neither can it be dismissed without analysis.

(c) The time at which the scheme was entered into and the length of the period during which it was carried out. Consider what the timing reveals in context.

 

Application:

The example gives no dates or intervals.

Closely coordinated incorporation and acquisition could be consistent with an agreed commercial merger. There is no obvious commercial requirement that Mary operate the business through New Co for an extended period before Sisters Co acquires it.

The period for which New Co continues to hold or operate the business after acquisition may also illuminate its function.

Criticism:

The example does not explain why the sequencing or duration indicates tax-driven contrivance rather than efficient implementation of the merger.

Potential weight:

Neutral or limited on the stated facts.

Rapid succession alone should not be treated as establishing a lack of commercial purpose.

(d) The result in relation to the operation of the Act that, but for Part IVA, would be achieved by the scheme. Identify the tax result without treating it as determinative. Neither choosing a tax-effective transaction nor identifying a more highly taxed alternative establishes dominant purpose by itself.
Application:

The immediate tax deferral is clear and intentional. It is a substantial explanation for choosing the rollover pathway.

But the subjective purpose that “Mary does not want to realise an immediate capital gain” and “Mary incorporates her business only to defer CGT” are different propositions.

Equally, Mary’s subjective purpose is irrelevant to this enquiry.

Incorporation may both implement a commercially preferred ownership structure and permit rollover treatment.

Criticism:

The example moves from the intended tax result to dominant purpose without explaining why the commercial attributes of incorporation and subsidiary ownership are subordinate.

Potential weight:

Towards tax purpose, particularly in explaining the choice of route. Its relative importance must be assessed against the genuine structural and ownership outcomes.

(e) Any change in the financial position of the relevant taxpayer that has resulted, will result, or may reasonably be expected to result, from the scheme. Examine the actual financial changes and whether they supply meaningful competing explanations.

 

Application:

Mary exchanges direct ownership of her business assets for an interest in Sisters Co and the combined enterprise. She gives up exclusive ownership and control in return for the contemplated participation of her sisters and an interest in the existing corporate business.

The financial significance depends on valuations, share allocations and the contributions expected from each sister.

Nevertheless, the example expressly identifies an expansion and shared-ownership arrangement, not an economically unchanged holding.

Criticism:

In the example those changes are not evaluated. The analysis should also distinguish benefits of the merger generally from benefits of holding Mary’s business through New Co.

Potential weight:

Supports a substantial commercial purpose, although further evidence is needed to determine how strongly it explains the particular structure.

(f) Any change in the financial position of a connected person resulting or reasonably expected to result from the scheme. Examine the connected participants’ financial positions and the reality of asserted advantages.

 

Application:

Sisters Co acquires a company holding an operating business. The sisters obtain the contemplated indirect participation in Mary’s business, while the business gains their involvement.

A separately held subsidiary could also preserve the distinction between the two businesses’ assets, financial performance and operating exposures.

Those possibilities require evidence.

Criticism:

There is no examination of the financial implications for Sisters Co, New Co or the sisters.

Potential weight:

Potentially supports commercial purpose.

The subsidiary-specific advantages, rather than only the benefits of merger, require particular attention.

(g) Any other consequence for the relevant taxpayer or a connected person of the scheme having been entered into or carried out. Evaluate the practical, legal and regulatory consequences. Differences in legal arrangements matter where they provide a meaningful explanation for the transaction.
Application:

Relevant questions include whether incorporation and the subsidiary structure facilitate separate management, governance, financing, reporting, staged integration, future investment or disposal, and management of operating risks.

These are precisely the matters that must be examined before concluding New Co has no practical function. If New Co continues to hold and operate the business, its ongoing role is particularly important.

Criticism:

The example supplies the conclusion that should emerge from this inquiry – i.e. that there is a dominant purpose of deferring a capital gain – without conducting the inquiry. Nor does the example state facts excluding these possible functions.

Potential weight:

Potentially important support for commercial purpose, if supported by the arrangement and evidence. Merely listing theoretical advantages would not suffice.

(h) The nature of the business, family or other connection between the relevant taxpayer and the connected persons. Examine what the relationships reveal about the arrangement.

 

Application:

The sisters already conduct a business together through Sisters Co. Using that existing ownership vehicle as the parent of the combined enterprise has an evident potential business explanation.

Acquiring New Co may allow the existing business and Mary’s business to remain separately identifiable beneath common ownership.

The sisters are intended to share ownership and control. The example does not establish that their interests are nominal or controlled by Mary.

Criticism:

The family connection should not obscure the existing business relationship or the real change in ownership and control.

Potential weight:

Mixed, but capable of supporting the commercial explanation.

The relationships facilitate coordination, while also explaining why this particular merger and ownership structure were chosen.

Having gone through that process, in our view there is a strong basis for concluding that a court would not apply Part IVA in these circumstances. Had the Commissioner adopted the same analytical approach, taxpayers would have a clearer understanding of why the real commercial and economic differences have not been taken into account.

Submissions on the draft PCG 2026/D5 are due 11 December 2026.

In the meantime, for advisers planned rollover sequences, should be assessed on the basis that an overall commercial rationale may not secure a lower-risk classification. Consolidation and tax cost setting benefits warrant particular attention.

Contemporaneous records should explain each step’s commercial utility and when the later transaction was first contemplated. However, documentation cannot make an integrated plan independent: the concern is substantive, not simply evidentiary.

If you have any queries or wish to undertake a review of your current structures, please contact our Tax team. 


[1] PCG 2026/D5 Back-to-back CGT rollovers and Part IVA of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936